Skip to main content
Keys hanging on wall

Amara Cay Resort

Murder Mystery Weekend

Keith O'Leary and Margo Morrison have masterminded a unique and unforgettable evening that will put you smack dab in the middle of a homicide investigation.  Heralded by the media as a phenomenon and new form of audience participation theater, Keith & Margo's MURDER MYSTERY DINNERS offer a chilling opportunity for ordinary people with a passion for cold-blooded murder... slippery red herrings... diabolical clues... and ingenious detective work to indulge themselves in one of the most unusual, exhilarating, and spine-tingling experiences they've ever had! Who hasn't dreamed of beating Columbo to the punch or who hasn't wanted to be Jessica Fletcher or Hercule Poirot for a night? Well, now's your chance. Come match wits with our detectives, and to boot you'll enjoy the cuisine of one of the finest restaurants around.

Murder Mystery Weekend Includes:

  • Two nights’ accommodations
  • 3-day murder mystery adventure
  • Friday night cocktail party with hors d’oeuvres
  • Friday night dinner
  • Saturday breakfast, lunch, cocktail party, and dinner
  • Sunday morning breakfast or brunch

Book Now 

Terms & Conditions

* Not valid for existing reservations. Offer must be booked by September 17, 2023. Valid for stays through October 26-29, 2023. Discount is reduced on black-out dates. Not valid for group bookings or third-party reservations. A three-night minimum is required. Cocktail party is a cash bar; the package does not include the cost of any alcoholic beverages at the cocktail party. Food & beverage is not redeemable for cash value.

Share your Story #IslamoradaResortCollection

2 Adults, 0 Children
Book Today