Amara Cay Resort
Murder Mystery Weekend
Keith O'Leary and Margo Morrison have masterminded a unique and unforgettable evening that will put you smack dab in the middle of a homicide investigation. Heralded by the media as a phenomenon and new form of audience participation theater, Keith & Margo's MURDER MYSTERY DINNERS offer a chilling opportunity for ordinary people with a passion for cold-blooded murder... slippery red herrings... diabolical clues... and ingenious detective work to indulge themselves in one of the most unusual, exhilarating, and spine-tingling experiences they've ever had! Who hasn't dreamed of beating Columbo to the punch or who hasn't wanted to be Jessica Fletcher or Hercule Poirot for a night? Well, now's your chance. Come match wits with our detectives, and to boot you'll enjoy the cuisine of one of the finest restaurants around.
Murder Mystery Weekend Includes:
- Two nights’ accommodations
- 3-day murder mystery adventure
- Friday night cocktail party with hors d’oeuvres
- Friday night dinner
- Saturday breakfast, lunch, cocktail party, and dinner
- Sunday morning breakfast or brunch
Terms & Conditions
* Not valid for existing reservations. Offer must be booked by September 17, 2023. Valid for stays through October 26-29, 2023. Discount is reduced on black-out dates. Not valid for group bookings or third-party reservations. A three-night minimum is required. Cocktail party is a cash bar; the package does not include the cost of any alcoholic beverages at the cocktail party. Food & beverage is not redeemable for cash value.
Other Offers You May Enjoy
Amara Cay Resort
Babymoon Bliss
Amara Cay Resort in the Florida Keys is a babymoon destination that will have you feeling pampered before the arrival of your baby.
Islamorada Resort Collection
200th Anniversary Sale - Islamorada Resort Collection
Celebrate The Florida Keys’ 200th anniversary and the island’s place in Florida’s history.
Islamorada Resort Collection
Florida & Georgia Resident Special - Islamorada Resort Collection
Kick back and relax on a tropical beach vacation. We offer Florida and Georgia residents up to 20% off our best available rate.
La Siesta Resort & Villas
Home Sweet Islamorada
Don't miss these exclusive savings on our unique villas in Islamorada.
La Siesta Resort & Villas | Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina
Splash & Play in the Ocean
Enjoy the Ultimate Thrill Ride. Our incredible island jetski tour takes you through over 26 miles of the most beautiful waters and scenery the Florida Keys has to offer.
Love Me Knot Reception Package
Celebrate after your ceremony with bar service, champagne toast, and a custom menu.
Brunch & Bubbly Reception Package
After an evening of wedding magic, treat everyone to breakfast with custom omelets and bubbles.
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina | Amara Cay Resort
BYOB - Bring Your Own Boat
Navigate our crystal clear waters and experience the exhilarating boating the Florida Keys has to offer – all from your own boat.
Islamorada Resort Collection
Salute Our Heroes - Islamorada Resort Collection
Current and former military, fire rescue, law enforcement, medical personnel, and teachers - enjoy discounts on your stay and resort credit!