Amara Cay Menu

Starters

• Crispy Cauliflower Bites

  8
  Served with sweety drop peppers, mango sweet chili sauce

• Waffle Fries

  8
  Old-bay dusted

• Chicken Wings

  16
  Buffalo, spicy thai, garlic teriyaki, or honey bbq

• Boneless Wings

  14
  Buffalo, spicy thai, garlic teriyaki, or honey bbq

• Chips & Dips

  10
  Tri-color corn tortillas with guacamole, salsa, & warm queso

• Chicken Nachos

  14
  Shredded chicken, jack cheese, jalapenos, cheese sauce, black bean, & corn salsa

• Jumbo Soft Pretzel

  7
  Served with horseradish mustard

Tacos & More

• Fish Tacos

  18
  Soft flour tortilla, lettuce, queso blanco, roasted black bean & corn salsa

• Chicken Quesadilla

  18
  Pickled red onions, jack cheese, jalapenos, roasted black bean & corn salsa
  • Shrimp $6.00

• Caribbean Lobster Tacos *

  22
  Island slaw, tropical salsa, soft flour tortilla, blackened or fried

Seafood Snacks

• Crispy Lobster Bites *

  18
  Florida lobster, sweet chili tartar

• Smoked Fish Dip

  12
  Pickled onions, jalapenos, served with tri-colored corn tortilla chips

• Ahi Tuna Poke *

  22
  Poke sauce, pickled ginger, crispy wonton chips, scallions

• Frito Misto Calamari *

  16
  Pickled peppers, dragon aioli

• Grouper Cheeks

  18
  With cilantro aioli

Salads & Wraps

• Chopped Wedge

  10
  Iceberg lettuce, heirloom tomatoes, bacon, gorgonzola crumbles, creamy blue cheese
  • gluten-free

• Chicken Caesar Salad

  14
  Romaine, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing, croutons
  • Shrimp $10.00
  • Fish $14.00

• Fresh Cut Watermelon Salad

  12
  Basil, mint, feta cheese, balsamic drizzle
  • gluten-free

• Chicken Caesar Wrap

  16
  Romaine, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing
  • Shrimp $8.00
  • Fish $12.00

Burgers & Sandwiches

• Light House Burger *

  18
  Lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, toasted brioche bun

• Black & Blue Burger *

  20
  Caramelized onions, lettuce, apple-wood smoked bacon, blue cheese, toasted brioche bun

• BBQ Bacon Sliders *

  16
  Cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon, bbq sauce

• Fishmonger Sandwich

  18
  Local fish, provolone cheese, tomato, avocado, sweet chili tartar, toasted challah bun grilled, blackened or beer-battered

• Cuban Sandwich

  18
  Hand-pressed cuban on toasted baguette, sliced pork, ham, swiss cheese, pickles, creamy mustard sauce

• Hot Chick Sandwich

  18
  Herb-marinated grilled chicken breast, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, dragon aioli, toasted challah bread

Entrees

• Filet Mignon *

  49
  Grilled 8oz filet, butter whipped potatoes, fresh vegetable medley

• Seafood Pasta *

  41
  Clams, mussels, florida lobster, shrimp, and fish, fettuccini pasta with marinara sauce

• Herb Roasted Half Chicken

  29
  Butter whipped potatoes, fresh vegetable medley, citrus beurre blanc
  • gluten-free

Desserts

• 5 Layer Chocolate Cake

  10

• New York Cheesecake

  10

• Key Lime Pie

  10

• Gelatys Gelato Pop

  7

Sparkling

• La Marca, Prosecco

• JP. Chenet, Brut

• Korbel, Brut

  40

• Veuve Clicquot Yellow Label

  100

Rose

• Charles & Charles

White

• Eroica, Riesling Columbia Valley

  13

• La Crema, Pinot Gris

• Ecco Domani, Pinot Grigio

• Matanzas Creek, Sauvignon Blanc

• Kim Crawford, Sauvignon Blanc

• Kendall Jackson, Chardonnay

• Complicated, Chardonnay

• Sonoma-Cutrer, Chardonnay

Reds

• Inscription, Pinot Noir

  14

• La Crema, Pinot Noir

• If You Say Kay - Lazio, Red Blend

  54

• H3 Horse Heaven Hills, Merlot

  10

• Alamos, Malbec

• Shatter, Grenache

  10

• Proverb, Cabernet Sauvignon

• Juggernuat, Cabernet Sauvignon

• Louis Martini, Cabernet Sauvignon

Keys Cocktails

• Frozen Tropical Breeze

  14
  Mango, strawberry, and passion fruit purée blended with coconut dark rum

• Classic Rum Runner

  14
  Hand shaken bacardi superior rum, dark rum, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, pineapple, grenadine

• Killer Colada

  14
  Cruzan rum, cream of coconut, fresh pineapple and pineapple juice, bacardi oakheart spiced rum

• Key Lime Colada

  14
  Frozen blended bacardi coconut and light rum, keke key lime liqueur, pineapple juice, and coco lopez

• Mango & Mint Spiced Daiquiri

  14
  Creamy blend of bacardi oakheart spiced rum, fresh mint, mango, and squeezed lime

• Wacky Daiquiri

  14
  Frozen blend of cruzan white rum. choice of strawberry/mango/lime/banana

• Miami Vice

  14
  Frozen blended mix of our strawberry daiquiri and pina colada

• Mango Tango Slush

  14
  Exotico tequila, amaretto, mango purée and lime juice

• Rock-A-Rita

  14
  Bacardi coconut rum, tequila, fresh lime, orange and pineapple juices, agave nectar

• Amara Cay Punch

  14
  Bacardi coconut and dark rum, orange, lime, and pineapple juices with grenadine

• Strawberry Mo-Tito

  14
  Tito's handmade vodka, muddled fresh, strawberries, limes, mint leaves, and agave nectar, topped with club soda

• American Mule

  14
  Tito's handmade vodka, ginger beer and fresh lime juice

• Sunset Lemonade

  14
  New amsterdam vodka, muddled fresh blueberries and pineapple, fresh pressed lemon juice, agave nectar, and club soda

Hand Crafted Martinis

• Strawberry Lemon Drop

  16
  Vodka, triple sec, pink lemonade, fresh strawberries, fresh lemon juice

• Chocolate Cake

  16
  Vanilla vodka, frangelico, sugar rim, grilled lemon wheel

• Banana Nut

  16
  Vanilla vodka, frangelico, banana liqueur, crushed honey peanut rim

• Key Lime

  16
  Keke beach key lime pie cream liqueur, vanilla vodka, lime juice, agave, graham cracker rim

Beers

Domestic

• Budweiser

• Bud Light

• Coors Light

• Miller Light

• Michelob Ultra

Locally Crafted

• Islamorada Brewing Co.

• Channel Marker IPA

• Sandbar Sunday Wheat Ale

• 3 Daughters Beach Blonde Ale

Imported

• Modelo

• Blue Moon

• Corona

• Heineken

• Stella Artois

• Sam Adams

• Yuengling

• Truly

• High Noon

On Tap

• Bud Light

• Islamorada Ale

• Key West Crazy Lady

• Stella Artois

• Sam Adams Seasonal

• Modelo

Zero Proof

• John Daley's Day Off

  0
  Cucumber lemonade, ginger beer, mint simple syrup

• That First Crush

  0
  Pink grapefruit juice, elderflower and fennel simple syrup, soda water, shaved fennel and fennel frons as garnish

• Be My Honeysuckle

  0
  Apricot spritzer, honeysuckle tea, simple syrup, fried sage garnish

• Cuddles on the Beach

  0
  Jarritos mandarin, hibiscus tea floater, thyme garnish

• IRC Sunrise

  0
  Cold brew hojicha, grenadine, lemon juice

• Orange Cream

  0
  Fresh squeezed orange juice, maple syrup, oat milk

• Yuzu Heat

  0
  Fresh pressed apple juice, organic yuzu juice, sparkling water, honey shichimi togarashi simple syrup