Amara Cay Menu

Lunch

Small Bites

• Crispy Calamari

  17
  Herb buttermilk battered, artichokes, sweet peppers, citrus caper aioli

• Chilled Pink Shrimp Cocktail

  22
  Half dozen local peel and eat shrimp, cocktail sauce

• Burrata Caprese

  16
  Heirloom tomato, fresh mozzarella, cucumber, basil, olive oil, aged balsamic, focaccia croutons

• Harissa Honey Chicken Wings

  18
  Half dozen jumbo wings, house made tzatziki sauce

• Tuscan Caesar

  15
  Fresh romaine, anchovy vinaigrette, olives, tomato, focaccia croutons
  • Chicken $8.00
  • Blackened Mahi $10.00
  • Garlic Shrimp $12.00

• Crushed Avocado

  12
  Fresh tomato salsa, warm tortilla chips

Roman Style Flatbreads

• Fig and Prosciutto

  23
  White sauce, prosciutto, tomato, shaved onion, arugula, olive oil

• SBLT

  25
  Marinated shrimp, old bay, applewood smoked bacon, arugula, roasted tomato

• Greek Chicken

  19
  Red sauce, feta cheese, olives, pepperoncini

Handhelds

• Fresh Catch Po'boy

  24
  Crispy battered local catch, toasted hoagie roll, spicy remoulade, cabbage slaw, tomato, red onion

• Island Bacon Pineapple Burger

  20
  Two four-ounce angus beef patties, applewood smoked bacon, grilled pineapple, grilled onion, cheddar cheese, brioche bun, teriyaki sauce

• Herb-Grilled Mahi Gyro

  27
  Toasted naan, roasted tomato, arugula, feta, tzatziki olive oil, lemon

• Italian Club

  19
  Prosciutto, shaved ham, genoa salami, burrata cheese, rosemary focaccia, basil, tomato, olive, and artichokes

• Lobster Tacos

  34
  Lobster meat, cabbage slaw, avocado, local citrus, remoulade

Bowls

• Hummus Bowl

  16
  Traditional chickpea hummus, edamame, marinated tomato, olive and cucumber salad, warmed naan

• Blackened Mahi Bowl

  24
  Roasted corn salsa, cilantro rice, marinated cabbage, guacamole, lemon caper sauce, tortilla chips

• Mediterranean Chicken Bowl

  20
  Marinated chicken breast, romaine lettuce, hummus kalamata olives, tomato, red onion, cucumber, feta vinaigrette, naan bread

• Garlic Shrimp Bowl

  22
  Citrus marinated shrimp, cilantro rice, cucumber tzatziki sauce, shaved cabbage, fresh vegetable salad, naan

• Ahi Tuna Bowl

  23
  Sesame seaweed salad, cilantro rice, cucumber edamame, avocado, toasted sesame seed, wonton strips, teriyaki ponzu, spicy aioli

Dessert

• Chocolate Marquis

  12

• Key Lime Pie

  13

White

• Sparkling, La Marca Prosecco, Italy

• Rose, Daou, Paso Robles, California

• Chardonnay, Franciscan Estate, California

• Sauvignon Blanc, Charlotte's Home, California

• Pinot Grigio, Ruffino Lumina, Italy

Red

• Pinot Noir, Sea Sun by Caymus, California

• Cabernet, Bonanza by Caymus, California

• Merlot, St. Francis, California

Beer & Seltzer

Domestic

• Bud Light

• Michelob Ultra

• Voodoo Ranger Juicy Haze IPA

Imported

• Corona Light

• Heineken

• Stella Artois

Draft

• Blue Moon

• Samuel Adams Seasonal

• Modelo

• Crazy Lady Blonde Ale

• FKBC Sun Session IPA

• FKBC Iguana Bait Hibiscus Kölsch

• Islamorada Brewing Channel Marker IPA

Seltzers

• Truly

• Ketel One Peach & Orange

• Ketel One Cucumber & Mint

Zero-Proof Cocktails

• Virgin Margarita

  Ritual tequila alternative, lime juice, agave nectar, salt rim

• Virgin Mojito

  Ritual rum alternative, soda water, fresh mint

• Virgin Cosmopolitan

  Ritual gin alternative, lime juice, cranberry juice, orange juice, simple syrup

Keys Cocktails

• Classic Rum Runner

  14
  Bacardi superior, bacardi black, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, orange, pineapple, grenadine, lime

• Frozen Tropical Breeze

  14
  Mango, strawberry purée, passion fruit purée, blended with rumhaven coconut

• Islamorada Colada

  14
  Cruzan rum, cream of coconut, pineapple

• Tai'd to the Dock

  18
  Appleton reserve rum, diplomático reserva, orgeat syrup, dry curaçao, lime juice

• Amara Cay Margarita

  22
  Mi campo reposado tequila, solerno orange liqueur, pineapple juice, blue curaçao, lime

• Summer on the Coast

  14
  New amsterdam vodka, aperol, lemon juice, simple syrup, mint leaves

• Ocean Eyes

  18
  New amsterdam gin, st~germain, chambord, lime juice, prosecco

• Hot Chili

  14
  New amsterdam raspberry vodka, triple sec, jalapeños, lime juice, cranberry juice

• Village of Islands Rita

  22
  Tres generaciones añejo, solerno blood orange liqueur, orange juice, lime

• Amara Cay Punch

  14
  Bacardi superior, bacardi black, amaretto, orange juice, pineapple juice, grenadine

• Blueberry Mojito

  15
  Smirnoff blueberry vodka, muddled fresh blueberries, lime, mint leaves, simple syrup, club soda

Other

• Water

  4

• Redbull & Redbull Sugar Free

  6

Dinner

Bites

• Crispy Calamari

  17
  Herb buttermilk battered, artichokes, sweet peppers, citrus caper aioli

• Chilled Pink Shrimp Cocktail

  22
  Half dozen local peel and eat shrimp, cocktail sauce

• Burrata Caprese

  16
  Heirloom tomato, fresh mozzarella, cucumber, basil olive oil, aged balsamic, focaccia croutons

• Sauteed Mussels

  19
  Bacon, garlic, onion, tomato, white wine butter sauce, herbed crostini

• SBLT Flatbread

  25
  Marinated shrimp, old bay, applewood smoked bacon arugula, roasted tomato

• Quattro Formaggio Flatbread

  17
  Mozzarella, reggiano, provolone, pecorino

• Harissa Honey Chicken Wings

  18
  Half dozen sweet and spicy jumbo wings served with our house made tzatziki sauce

• Tuscan Caesar

  15
  Fresh romaine, anchovy vinaigrette, olives, tomato, focaccia croutons

• Ahi Tuna Bowl

  23
  Sesame seaweed salad, cilantro rice, cucumber edamame, avocado, toasted sesame seed, wonton strips, teriyaki ponzu, spicy aioli

• Mediterranean Chicken Bowl

  20
  Marinated chicken breast, romaine lettuce, hummus kalamata olives, tomato, red onion, cucumber, feta vinaigrette, naan bread

• Island Bacon Pineapple Burger

  20
  8oz angus beef patty, applewood smoked bacon, grilled pineapple, grilled onion, cheddar cheese, brioche bun, teriyaki sauce

Dessert

• Lemon Shortbread

  12

• Pistachio Ricotta Cream Cake

  13

• Chocolate Marquis

  12

• Key Lime Pie

  13

White

• Sparkling, La Marca Prosecco, Italy

• Rose, Daou, Paso Robles, California

• Chardonnay, Franciscan Estate, California

• Sauvignon Blanc, Charlotte's Home, California

• Pinot Grigio, Ruffino Lumina, Italy

Red

• Pinot Noir, Sea Sun by Caymus, California

• Cabernet, Bonanza by Caymus, California

• Merlot, St. Francis, California

White by the Bottle

• Sparkling, Moet & Chandon, Champagne, France

  160

• Sparkling, Veuve Clicquot, Champagne, France

  210

• Rose, Miraval, Cotes de Provence, France

  65

• Fume Blanc, Ferrari Carano, North Coast, California

  55

• Sauvignon Blanc, Whitehaven, Marlborough, New Zealand

  50

• Chardonnay, Boen, California

  55

• Chardonnay, Cakebread, Carneros, California

  140

• White blend, E. Guigal, Cotes du Rhone, France

  65

Red by the Bottle

• Cabernet Sauvignon, Daou Reserve, Paso Robles, California

  140

• Cabernet Sauvignon, Caymus

  265

• Merlot, Duckhorn, Napa Valley, California

  130

• Merlot, Educated Guess, Napa Valley

  70

• Pinot Noir, Belle Glos, California

  125

• Pinot Noir Paul Hobbs, "Russian River", California

  192

• Red Blend, Caymus "The Walking Fool", Suisun Valley, California

  60

• Red Blend, Orin Swift "8 Years In the Dessert", California

  128

Beer & Seltzer

Domestic

• Bud Light

• Michelob Ultra

• Voodoo Ranger Juicy Haze IPA

Imported

• Corona Light

• Heineken

• Stella Artois

Draft

• Blue Moon

• Samuel Adams Seasonal

• Modelo

• Crazy Lady Blonde Ale

• FKBC Sun Session IPA

• FKBC Iguana Bait Hibiscus Kölsch

• Islamorada Brewing Channel Marker IPA

Seltzers

• Truly

• Ketel One Peach & Orange

• Ketel One Cucumber & Mint

Other

• Water

  4

• Redbull & Redbull Sugar Free

  6

Keys Cocktails

• Classic Rum Runner

  14
  Bacardi superior, bacardi black, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, orange, pineapple, grenadine, lime

• Dragon Ball

  14
  New amsterdam gin, midori melon, lime juice, fever-tree elderflower tonic

• Café Old Fashioned

  21
  Diplomático rum, maker's mark bourbon, coffee liqueur, orange bitters

• Amara Essences

  17
  Ketel one botanical peach, orange blossom, strawberry pureé, lemon juice, prosseco

• I Need a Hot One

  19
  Ilegal mezcal, ancho reyes chile liqueur, grand marnier, pineapple juice, lime juice

• All Eyes on Me

  15
  Pusser's rum, pineapple juice, nonino amaro, lime juice, coco lopez, nutmeg

• Blueberry Mojito

  15
  Smirnoff blueberry vodka, muddled fresh blueberries, lime, mint leaves, simple syrup, club soda

Handcrafted Martinis

• The 305

  15
  Cruzan guava rum, passion fruit pureé, lime juice, simple syrup

• Thyme Splash

  15
  Tanqueray no. ten, cucumber, fresh thyme, lime juice, simple syrup, white cranberry juice

• Amara Sensational

  17
  Islamorada hibiscus gin, st germain liqueur, lemon juice, simple syrup

• Espresso Martini

  17
  Vanilla vodka, mr black coffee liqueur, baileys, espresso shot

Zero-Proof Cocktails

• Virgin Margarita

  Ritual tequila alternative, lime juice, agave nectar, salt rim

• Virgin Mojito

  Ritual rum alternative, soda water, fresh mint

• Virgin Cosmopolitan

  Ritual gin alternative, lime juice, cranberry juice, orange juice, simple syrup

Main

• Mac & Cheese

  13
  Elbow macaroni with cheesy sauce

• Grilled Chicken

  13
  Choice of side

• Caesar Salad

  11
  Romaine, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing, croutons
  • Add Chicken $4.00

• Chicken Fingers

  14
  French fries, honey mustard

• Mini Burger

  15
  American cheese, housemade potato chips

Sides

• Housemade Potato Chips

  6

• Fruit Cup

  6

Desserts

• Three Housemade Cookies

  8

• Gelatys Pop

  12

• Brownie

  7

Hydrations

• Milk

  4
  Whole, 2% or chocolate

• Fruit Juice

  4
  Apple, pineapple, cranberry, orange or grapefruit

• Soda

  4
  Coke, diet coke, sprite, ginger ale or pink lemonade