Refined, Real Relaxation
Vacation at your own pace at Amara Cay Resort. Our boutique spaces bring a vibe of luxe leisure while staying true to the effortless simplicity the Keys are famous for. Discover captivating views of the Alligator Reef Lighthouse, and boating excursions and amenities that let you embrace authentic island life. Spend a day on the water full of adventure, or lounge on the beach and enjoy the blissful art of doing nothing at all—your choice.
With coastal chic style and a host of modern amenities, you’re never too far from stunning ocean views or the bliss of basking by the pool at our Islamorada resort. Discover our spacious rooms and suites with private balconies and lanais that celebrate sophisticated island style.
Amara Cay Resort
Babymoon Bliss
Amara Cay Resort in the Florida Keys is a babymoon destination that will have you feeling pampered before the arrival of your baby.
Islamorada Resort Collection
200th Anniversary Sale - Islamorada Resort Collection
Celebrate The Florida Keys’ 200th anniversary and the island’s place in Florida’s history.
Islamorada Resort Collection
Florida & Georgia Resident Special - Islamorada Resort Collection
Kick back and relax on a tropical beach vacation. We offer Florida and Georgia residents up to 20% off our best available rate.
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina | Amara Cay Resort
BYOB - Bring Your Own Boat
Navigate our crystal clear waters and experience the exhilarating boating the Florida Keys has to offer – all from your own boat.
Islamorada Resort Collection
Salute Our Heroes - Islamorada Resort Collection
Current and former military, fire rescue, law enforcement, medical personnel, and teachers - enjoy discounts on your stay and resort credit!
Amara Cay Resort
Murder Mystery Weekend
Join us this Halloween and become a leading suspect in a homicide investigation!
Take it easy with chill beachside yoga or a relaxing stand-up paddle session, or turn up the excitement with ocean adventures sure to thrill.
Dine & Drink
Get social and savor fresh island flavors. Refreshing drinks and warm ocean breezes await at the poolside Tiki Bar, while ReelCatch and Coastal Cup flow seamlessly from breakfast, to lunch, to dinner.
Meetings
Break from convention and bring your group beachside. Perfect for incentive trips and smaller corporate gatherings, ample leisure time is always on the agenda at Amara Cay.
Weddings
Say “I Do” under swaying palms and celebrate island-style in your own private tiki. Let Islamorada’s natural beauty be your backdrop for celebrating new beginnings.
Marina
Your stay at Amara Cay brings access to all the amenities of our three sister resorts. Dock with us any time of year at our marina and enjoy easy access to Islamorada fishing, boating, watersports and more.