Skip to main content
couple have a glass or wine at the outside bar

Tiki Bar

A Classic Keys Experience

Hop out of the pool and dive into classic Americana at Tiki Bar. Open for lunch and dinner, this breezy poolside favorite is the perfect setting for sipping tropical cocktails paired with tempting bar bites.

Enjoy delectable tacos, island-inspired seafood specialties, and enticing entrées followed by a slice of heaven—real Key Lime Pie beneath swaying palms.

Menus

Starters

  • Crispy Cauliflower Bites

    8
    Served with sweety drop peppers, mango sweet chili sauce
  • Waffle Fries

    8
    Old-bay dusted
  • Chicken Wings

    16
    Buffalo, spicy thai, garlic teriyaki, or honey bbq
  • Boneless Wings

    14
    Buffalo, spicy thai, garlic teriyaki, or honey bbq
  • Chips & Dips

    10
    Tri-color corn tortillas with guacamole, salsa, & warm queso
  • Chicken Nachos

    14
    Shredded chicken, jack cheese, jalapenos, cheese sauce, black bean, & corn salsa
  • Jumbo Soft Pretzel

    7
    Served with horseradish mustard

Tacos & More

  • Fish Tacos

    18
    Soft flour tortilla, lettuce, queso blanco, roasted black bean & corn salsa
  • Chicken Quesadilla

    18
    Pickled red onions, jack cheese, jalapenos, roasted black bean & corn salsa
    • Shrimp $6.00
  • Caribbean Lobster Tacos *

    22
    Island slaw, tropical salsa, soft flour tortilla, blackened or fried

Seafood Snacks

  • Crispy Lobster Bites *

    18
    Florida lobster, sweet chili tartar
  • Smoked Fish Dip

    12
    Pickled onions, jalapenos, served with tri-colored corn tortilla chips
  • Ahi Tuna Poke *

    22
    Poke sauce, pickled ginger, crispy wonton chips, scallions
  • Frito Misto Calamari *

    16
    Pickled peppers, dragon aioli
  • Grouper Cheeks

    18
    With cilantro aioli

Salads & Wraps

  • Chopped Wedge

    10
    Iceberg lettuce, heirloom tomatoes, bacon, gorgonzola crumbles, creamy blue cheese
    • gluten-free
  • Chicken Caesar Salad

    14
    Romaine, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing, croutons
    • Shrimp $10.00
    • Fish $14.00
  • Fresh Cut Watermelon Salad

    12
    Basil, mint, feta cheese, balsamic drizzle
    • gluten-free
  • Chicken Caesar Wrap

    16
    Romaine, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing
    • Shrimp $8.00
    • Fish $12.00

Burgers & Sandwiches

  • Light House Burger *

    18
    Lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, toasted brioche bun
  • Black & Blue Burger *

    20
    Caramelized onions, lettuce, apple-wood smoked bacon, blue cheese, toasted brioche bun
  • BBQ Bacon Sliders *

    16
    Cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon, bbq sauce
  • Fishmonger Sandwich

    18
    Local fish, provolone cheese, tomato, avocado, sweet chili tartar, toasted challah bun grilled, blackened or beer-battered
  • Cuban Sandwich

    18
    Hand-pressed cuban on toasted baguette, sliced pork, ham, swiss cheese, pickles, creamy mustard sauce
  • Hot Chick Sandwich

    18
    Herb-marinated grilled chicken breast, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, dragon aioli, toasted challah bread

Entrees

Available after 5pm
  • Filet Mignon *

    49
    Grilled 8oz filet, butter whipped potatoes, fresh vegetable medley
  • Seafood Pasta *

    41
    Clams, mussels, florida lobster, shrimp, and fish, fettuccini pasta with marinara sauce
  • Herb Roasted Half Chicken

    29
    Butter whipped potatoes, fresh vegetable medley, citrus beurre blanc
    • gluten-free

Desserts

  • 5 Layer Chocolate Cake

    10
  • New York Cheesecake

    10
  • Key Lime Pie

    10
  • Gelatys Gelato Pop

    7
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical condition
Single Platform banner

Sparkling

  • La Marca, Prosecco

  • JP. Chenet, Brut

  • Korbel, Brut

    40
  • Veuve Clicquot Yellow Label

    100

Rose

  • Charles & Charles

White

  • Eroica, Riesling Columbia Valley

    13
  • La Crema, Pinot Gris

  • Ecco Domani, Pinot Grigio

  • Matanzas Creek, Sauvignon Blanc

  • Kim Crawford, Sauvignon Blanc

  • Kendall Jackson, Chardonnay

  • Complicated, Chardonnay

  • Sonoma-Cutrer, Chardonnay

Reds

  • Inscription, Pinot Noir

    14
  • La Crema, Pinot Noir

  • If You Say Kay - Lazio, Red Blend

    54
  • H3 Horse Heaven Hills, Merlot

    10
  • Alamos, Malbec

  • Shatter, Grenache

    10
  • Proverb, Cabernet Sauvignon

  • Juggernuat, Cabernet Sauvignon

  • Louis Martini, Cabernet Sauvignon

Keys Cocktails

  • Frozen Tropical Breeze

    14
    Mango, strawberry, and passion fruit purée blended with coconut dark rum
  • Classic Rum Runner

    14
    Hand shaken bacardi superior rum, dark rum, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, pineapple, grenadine
  • Killer Colada

    14
    Cruzan rum, cream of coconut, fresh pineapple and pineapple juice, bacardi oakheart spiced rum
  • Key Lime Colada

    14
    Frozen blended bacardi coconut and light rum, keke key lime liqueur, pineapple juice, and coco lopez
  • Mango & Mint Spiced Daiquiri

    14
    Creamy blend of bacardi oakheart spiced rum, fresh mint, mango, and squeezed lime
  • Wacky Daiquiri

    14
    Frozen blend of cruzan white rum. choice of strawberry/mango/lime/banana
  • Miami Vice

    14
    Frozen blended mix of our strawberry daiquiri and pina colada
  • Mango Tango Slush

    14
    Exotico tequila, amaretto, mango purée and lime juice
  • Rock-A-Rita

    14
    Bacardi coconut rum, tequila, fresh lime, orange and pineapple juices, agave nectar
  • Amara Cay Punch

    14
    Bacardi coconut and dark rum, orange, lime, and pineapple juices with grenadine
  • Strawberry Mo-Tito

    14
    Tito's handmade vodka, muddled fresh, strawberries, limes, mint leaves, and agave nectar, topped with club soda
  • American Mule

    14
    Tito's handmade vodka, ginger beer and fresh lime juice
  • Sunset Lemonade

    14
    New amsterdam vodka, muddled fresh blueberries and pineapple, fresh pressed lemon juice, agave nectar, and club soda

Hand Crafted Martinis

  • Strawberry Lemon Drop

    16
    Vodka, triple sec, pink lemonade, fresh strawberries, fresh lemon juice
  • Chocolate Cake

    16
    Vanilla vodka, frangelico, sugar rim, grilled lemon wheel
  • Banana Nut

    16
    Vanilla vodka, frangelico, banana liqueur, crushed honey peanut rim
  • Key Lime

    16
    Keke beach key lime pie cream liqueur, vanilla vodka, lime juice, agave, graham cracker rim

Beers

Domestic

$5
  • Budweiser

  • Bud Light

  • Coors Light

  • Miller Light

  • Michelob Ultra

Locally Crafted

$6
  • Islamorada Brewing Co.

  • Channel Marker IPA

  • Sandbar Sunday Wheat Ale

  • 3 Daughters Beach Blonde Ale

Imported

$7
  • Modelo

  • Blue Moon

  • Corona

  • Heineken

  • Stella Artois

  • Sam Adams

  • Yuengling

  • Truly

  • High Noon

On Tap

  • Bud Light

  • Islamorada Ale

  • Key West Crazy Lady

  • Stella Artois

  • Sam Adams Seasonal

  • Modelo

Single Platform banner

Zero Proof

  • John Daley's Day Off

    0
    Cucumber lemonade, ginger beer, mint simple syrup
  • That First Crush

    0
    Pink grapefruit juice, elderflower and fennel simple syrup, soda water, shaved fennel and fennel frons as garnish
  • Be My Honeysuckle

    0
    Apricot spritzer, honeysuckle tea, simple syrup, fried sage garnish
  • Cuddles on the Beach

    0
    Jarritos mandarin, hibiscus tea floater, thyme garnish
  • IRC Sunrise

    0
    Cold brew hojicha, grenadine, lemon juice
  • Orange Cream

    0
    Fresh squeezed orange juice, maple syrup, oat milk
  • Yuzu Heat

    0
    Fresh pressed apple juice, organic yuzu juice, sparkling water, honey shichimi togarashi simple syrup
Single Platform banner

Events Calendar

Authentic island experiences are always on our calendar. See what’s happening at Amara Cay Resort. 

2 Adults, 0 Children
-
+
-
+
Book Today