Skip to main content
couple have a glass or wine at the outside bar

Tiki Bar

A Classic Keys Experience

Hop out of the pool and dive into classic Americana at Tiki Bar. Open for lunch and dinner, this breezy poolside favorite is the perfect setting for sipping tropical cocktails paired with tempting bar bites.

Enjoy delectable tacos, island-inspired seafood specialties, and enticing entrées followed by a slice of heaven—real Key Lime Pie beneath swaying palms.

Menus

First - Shareables

  • Island Calamari

    17
    Pickled peppers, dragon aioli
  • Smoked Fish Dip

    17
    Capers, red onions, pickled peppers, sesame flatbread crackers
  • Chicken Lollipops

    18
    Buffalo, jerk bbq or spicy thai
  • Crispy Cauliflower Bites

    16
    Mango sweet chili sauce
  • Ahi Tuna Poke

    22
    Spicy ponzu cucumber, avocado, wakame salad, wonton chips
  • Chilled Shrimp

    21
    Mango chili cocktail sauce

Second - Salads

Add Grilled, Blackened or Fried Chicken $8, Shrimp $11 or Fish $12
  • Fresh Cut Watermelon

    18
    Arugula, mint, cotija, pepitas, balsamic glaze
  • Key Lime Caesar

    17
    Hearts of romaine, parmesan, crispy cheese crisps, creamy key lime dressing
  • Roasted Beet

    17
    Goat cheese, salted almond crumble, mixed greens, oranges, florida citrus & riesling vinaigrette

Third - Mains

  • Florida Lobster Roll

    28
    Terragon, chives, butter-toasted brioche roll
  • Grouper Reuben

    22
    Swiss, sauerkraut, thousand island, rye bread
  • Fish Tacos

    22
    Fresh catch of the day, tropical salsa
  • Cubano

    21
    Sliced pork, ham, swiss, sweet pickles, creamy mustard, toasted baguette
  • Big Reef Burger* or Sub Veggie Burger

    23
    Griddled onions, crispy bibb lettuce, pickle, special sauce
  • Cheeks & Chips

    22
    Beer-battered grouper cheeks, cornichon aioli
  • Chicken B.L.A.T. Chapati

    21
    Grilled chicken, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, avocado, heirloom tomatoes, naan flatbread

Sides

  • French Fries

    8
  • Side Salad

    12
  • Fresh Fruit

    8

Fourth - Desserts

  • Key Lime Pie

    14
    Lime zest, toasted meringue
  • Chocolate Cake

    15
    Mixed berry compote, powdered sugar
  • Gelatys Gelato Pop

    12
  • Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

    14
    Bruléed pineapple, rum glaze
  • Tropical Thai-Style Donuts

    14
    Coconut condensed milk, mango

Sparkling

  • La Marca, Prosecco

  • Argyle, Vintage Brut Sparkling

Rosé

  • Château Miraval

White

  • Starmont, Chardonnay

  • Casa Lunardi, Pinot Grigio

  • Caposaldo, Moscato

  • Bravium, Chardonnay

  • Dr. Heyden, Riesling

  • Cloudy Bay, Sauvignon Blanc

Red

  • Markham, Merlot

  • Justin, Cabernet Sauvignon

  • Alamos, Malbec

  • Tutto Mio, Dulce Rosso

  • Substance, Cabernet Sauvignon

  • Davis Bynum, Pinot Noir

  • Unshackled, Red Blend

Cocktails

  • Classic Rum Runner

    17
    Bacardi superior, dark rum, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, orange, pineapple, grenadine, lime
  • Frozen Tropical Breeze

    17
    Mango, strawberry purée, passion fruit purée, blended with bacardi coconut
  • Islamorada Colada

    17
    Cruzan rum, cream of coconut, pineapple. or make it: killer - with bacardi black rum; key lime - with blue chair bay key lime rum cream; miami vice - with swirls of our strawberry daiquiri
    • Killer $7.00
    • Key Lime $7.00
    • Miami Vice $7.00
  • Tai'd to the Dock

    18
    Appleton reserve rum, diplomático reserva, orgeat syrup, dry curaçao, lime juice
  • Amara Cay Margarita

    18
    Reposado tequila, solerno orange liqueur, pineapple juice, blue curaçao, lime juice
  • Summer on the Coast

    16
    New amsterdam vodka, aperol, lemon juice, simple syrup, mint leaves
  • Ocean Eyes

    18
    New amsterdam gin, st~germain, chambord, lime juice, prosecco
  • Hot Chili

    17
    Raspberry vodka, triple sec, jalepeños, lime juice, cranberry juice
  • Village of Islands Rita

    18
    Tres generaciones añejo, solerno blood orange liqueur, orange juice, lime
  • Amara Cay Punch

    16
    Light rum, dark rum, amaretto, orange juice, pineapple juice, grenadine
  • Blueberry Mojito

    17
    Blueberry vodka, muddled fresh blueberries, lime, mint, simple syrup, club soda

Zero Proof

  • Virgin Margarita

    14
    Ritual tequila alternative, lime juice, agave nectar
  • Siesta

    14
    Ritual aperitif alternative, ritual tequila alternative, grapefruit juice, lime juice, simple syrup
  • Stay Classy

    14
    Ritual rum alternative, pineapplejuice, banana purée, lime juice

Cans

$8
  • Bud Light

  • Coors Light

  • Miller Lite

  • Michelob Ultra

  • Corona

  • Heineken

  • Heineken 0.0

  • Stella Artois

  • Truly Seltzer

Draft

$9
  • Blue Moon

  • Samuel Adams Seasonal

  • Modelo

  • Crazy Lady Blonde Ale

  • FKBC Sun Session IPA

  • FKBC Iguana Bait Hibiscus Kölsch

  • Islamorada Brewing Channel Marker IPA

*Consuming Raw or Undercooked Meats, Poultry, Seafood, Shellfish or Eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness
Single Platform banner

Main

  • Mac & Cheese

    13
    Elbow macaroni with cheesy sauce
  • Grilled Chicken

    13
    Choice of side
  • Caesar Salad

    11
    Romaine, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing, croutons
    • Add Chicken $4.00
  • Chicken Fingers

    14
    French fries, honey mustard
  • Mini Burger

    15
    American cheese, housemade potato chips

Sides

  • Housemade Potato Chips

    6
  • Fruit Cup

    6

Desserts

  • Three Housemade Cookies

    8
  • Gelatys Pop

    12
  • Brownie

    7

Hydrations

  • Milk

    4
    Whole, 2% or chocolate
  • Fruit Juice

    4
    Apple, pineapple, cranberry, orange or grapefruit
  • Soda

    4
    Coke, diet coke, sprite, ginger ale or pink lemonade
Single Platform banner

Events Calendar

Authentic island experiences are always on our calendar. See what’s happening at Amara Cay Resort. 

2 Adults, 0 Children
-
+
-
+
Book Today