Oceanfront Dining
Amara Cay Resort's dining and drink experiences lure locals and guests with cuisine that’s anchored in the traditions of the Florida Keys. Indulge at ReelCatch, Coastal Cup, or Tiki Bar any time of day. From classic burgers and succulent seafood, to custom-blended treats and top-shelf spirits, anything you choose will pair perfectly with our incredible ocean and Alligator Reef Lighthouse views.
Tiki Bar
Lunch
Mon - Thu | 11am start time
Fri - Sun | 11:30am start time
Bar
Sun-Thu | 11am – 9pm
Fri & Sat | 11am – 11pm
ReelCatch
Breakfast
Mon - Thu | 8am – 10:30am
Fri & Sat | 8am – 11am
Dinner
Sun - Thu | 5pm – 9pm
Fri & Sat | 5pm – 10pm
Coastal Cup & Lounge
Breakfast Grab 'N Go
Mon -Thu | 7am - 10:30am
Fri - Sun | 7am - 11am
Bar
Sun - Thu | 5pm - 10pm
Fri & Sat | 5pm - 11pm
Menu
In-Room Dining
Hours
Open Daily | 8am - 10am & 12pm – 8pm
More Dining Options at Islamorada Resort Collection
Your stay at Amara Cay gives you access to even more delicious dining at our three sister resorts.
Wild & Lime
Hours
Open Daily | 12pm – 6pm
ReelCatch
Breakfast
Mon - Thu | 8am – 10:30am
Fri & Sat | 8am – 11am
Dinner
Sun - Thu | 5pm – 9pm
Fri & Sat | 5pm – 10pm
Coastal Cup & Lounge
Breakfast Grab 'N Go
Mon -Thu | 7am - 10:30am
Fri - Sun | 7am - 11am
Bar
Sun - Thu | 5pm - 10pm
Fri & Sat | 5pm - 11pm
Menu
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina
Tiki Bar
Hours
Sun – Thurs | 8am – 12am
Fri - Sat | 8am - 1am
Tiki Bar
Lunch
Mon - Thu | 11am start time
Fri - Sun | 11:30am start time
Bar
Sun-Thu | 11am – 9pm
Fri & Sat | 11am – 11pm
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina
Kokomo Poolside Bar
Hours
Open Daily | 11am – 6pm
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina
Raw Bar
Hours
Dinner
Friday, Saturday
5:00PM-10:00PM
Lunch
Saturday, Sunday
11:00AM-5:00PM
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina
Starbucks
Hours
Open Daily | 6am – 8pm
Siesta Mercato
Hours
Open Daily | 7am - 11pm
In-Room Dining
Hours
Open Daily | 8am - 10am & 12pm – 8pm
Events Calendar
Authentic island experiences are always on our calendar. See what’s happening at Amara Cay Resort.