Islamorada Insiders

Islamorada Insiders is a lifetime loyalty program that rewards guests who stay at Amara Cay Resort and La Siesta Resort & Villas. Members earn exclusive benefits based on the total number of nights they have stayed across both resorts—your nights never reset, so your rewards only grow over time!

There’s no sign-up required! Your stays are automatically tracked, and once you reach a new tier, you’ll start receiving the associated benefits on your next stay.

Unlike many loyalty programs, Islamorada Insiders is based on your cumulative stays*, so your progress never resets. Once you reach a tier, you keep those benefits indefinitely. As soon as you reach a new tier, you’ll start enjoying your new rewards on your next stay.

*Cumulative stays since May 2023 at Amara Cay Resort and La Siesta Resort & Villas.

Yes! All of your nights at both resorts count toward your total, helping you unlock rewards faster.

You can contact us at [email protected] to check your current status and total nights stayed. As soon as you reach a new tier, you’ll receive an email notifying you of your new status and the included benefits.

As soon as you reach a new tier, you’ll start enjoying your rewards on your next stay.

While we do our best to honor these perks, early check-in, late check-out, and room upgrades depend on availability at the time of your stay.

No, nights and benefits are non-transferable and apply only to the guest who has accumulated the stays.

Gold and Platinum members receive a resort credit ($50 for Gold, $100 for Platinum) per stay to use toward dining, activities, and select services at the resort. The credit is applied at check-out.

The Welcome Amenity varies by season but is a special gift curated by the resort to enhance your stay.