Skip to main content
Friends having drinks in the pool at Amara Cay

Beach & Pool

At Amara Cay Resort, languid days at our pool and beach promise an elevated Keys experience. Discover an island escape that takes you far from your everyday to a place of sophisticated island bliss. 

woman in hammock at beach

Lighthouse Beach

Lay in a hammock or on a lounger under a thatched hut at our elevated sunning beach with incredible views of Alligator Reef Lighthouse. 

Amara Cay - pool


Relax and unwind at our zero-entry pool as palm trees sway in the breeze, with fresh seafood, frozen cocktails and more just steps away at Tiki Bar.

Pool: 8 am - Sunset
Tiki Bar: 12 pm - 6 pm

Poolside Cabanas

Retreat to the privacy of your poolside cabana with magnificent views of the Atlantic Ocean. Each poolside cabana reservation includes a $250 credit at our Tiki Bar.

2 Adults, 0 Children
Book Today