Starters & Snacks

• Homemade Smoked Fish Dip

  16
  Prepared with local catch, diced onions, jalapeños, pepperoncini, capers, tomatoes, lemon

• Chicken Wings

  16
  Choice of: traditional or boneless. choice of: buffalo, jerk, dry rub or bbq

• Coconut Fried Shrimp *

  14
  Mango chili, pineapple salsa

• Mahi Fish Bites

  18
  Lemon, yum yum sauce

• Chips & Dips

  10
  Tri-color corn tortillas with guacamole, pico de gallo & warm queso

• Jumbo Soft Pretzel

  10
  Served with horseradish mustard, queso

• French Fries

  8
  House seasoning

• Shrimp Cocktail

  20
  Served cold, with lemons & cocktail sauce

• Grilled Jerk Shrimp *

  20
  With pineapple salsa

Sandwiches

• PCI Burger

  18
  Signature blend of ground beef, american cheese, shredded lettuce, tomoato, oinion, pickles, housemade sauce, brioche bun

• Islamorada Fish Sandwich

  20
  Catch of the day (grilled, blackened, or fried) lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pickles, pineapple salsa, toasted bun, yum yum sauce

• Fried Chicken Sliders

  16
  Buttermilk fried, nashville hot sauce, sliced pickles, toasted bun

• Chicken/Shrimp* Quesadilla

  Flour tortilla, peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, guacamole, pico

Tacos

• Mahi Fish Tacos

  20
  Island slaw, pineapple salsa, yum yum sauce, soft flour tortilla (served hot)

• Ahi Tuna Tacos *

  22
  Avocado wakame seaweed salad, sriracha sauce, honey-wasabi aioli, soft flour tortillas

• Keys Blackened Mahi Salad

  20
  Mix greens, tomato, pineapple salsa, cucumber

Hook & Cook

• Hook & Cook

  16

Tiki Time Cocktails

• Rum Crawlers

  Cartel rum, diplomatico rum, appleton rum, orgeat, orange curacao, lime juice, cinnamon bitters

• The Good Keys Life

  Casamigos tequila, grand marnier, lime juice, earl grey agave

• Postcard Paloma

  Milagro tequila, giffard pamplemousse, lime juice, monin pineberry, grapefruit soda

• Smokey Tiki Rita

  Dos hombres mezcal, lime juice, simple syrup, top off red wine

• Overseas Sunset Sangria

  New amsterdam vodka, aperol, moscato, agave, passion fruit, merlot

• Indigo Midnight

  Woodford reserve, pineapple, orange juice, topped off with ginger beer

• Floridora Isladora

  Botanist gin, simple syrup, lime juice, raspberries, butterfly pea flowers

• Passion Por Mi Amor

  Don q rum, passion fruit, orange juice, campari

Frozen Favorites

• The Original Rum Runner

  Our signature cocktail since forever. frozen or hand shaken. bacardi superior rum, bacardi black, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, pineapple juice, lime juice, grenadine

• Cartel Colada

  Cartel rum, tropeka pina colada blend

• Key Lime Colada

  Keke beach key lime liqueur, bacardi, tropeka ice creme, lime juice, coco lopez

• Cartel Mudslide

  Cartel rum, creme de cocoa, tropeka ice creme, coco lopez

Wine

• Tutto Mio, Sweet Red

• St. Francis, Merlot

• Unshackled, Red Blend

• Substance, Cabernet Sauvignon

• Wycliff Sparkling

• Caposaldo, Moscato

• August Kessler, Riesling

• Casa Lunardi, Pinot Grigio, Italy

• Giesen, Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand

• Starmont, Chardonnay, California

• Daou, Rose

• Sea Sun, Pinot Noir, California

Beer

On Tap

• Sam Adams

• Corona

• Modelo

• Voodoo Ranger

• Blue Moon

• Lagunitas IPA

Local

• Crazy Lady Honey Blonde Ale

• Florida Keys Iguana Bait

• Islamorada Citrus Ale

• Islamorada Sandbar Sunday

• Florida Keys Spearfish Amber Ale

• Florida Keys Sunsessional IPA

Cans

• Bud Light

• Budweiser

• Coors Light

• Miller Light

• Michelob Ultra

• Truly Variety

• Corona Premier

• Heineken

• Stella Artois

• Sierra Nevada

• Angry Orchard Cider

Main

• Chicken Tenders

  10

• Hot Dog

  10

• Grilled Cheese

  10

• Mac And Cheese

  10

Zero Proof

• John Daley's Day Off

  Cucumber lemonade, ginger beer, mint simple syrup

• That First Crush

  Pink grapefruit juice, elderflower and fennel simple syrup, soda water, shaved fennel and fennel frons as garnish

• Be My Honeysuckle

  Apricot spritzer, honeysuckle tea, simple syrup, fried sage garnish

• Cuddles on the Beach

  Jarritos mandarin, hibiscus tea floater, thyme garnish

• IRC Sunrise

  Cold brew hojicha, grenadine, lemon juice

• Orange Cream

  Fresh squeezed orange juice, maple syrup, oat milk

• Yuzu Heat

  Fresh pressed apple juice, organic yuzu juice, sparkling water, honey shichimi togarashi simple syrup