Skip to main content

Tiki Bar

World-Famous Home of the Rum Runner

A long-time favorite haunt among locals and guests, Tiki Bar is a bucket-list-busting island institution worth the trip alone. Serving up tropical cocktails, fresh seafood, and good times for over 50 years, it's also home to the famed Rum Runner cocktail. A fabled libation created to use up surplus bar inventory, this legendary concoction pays homage to the Keys' early history as a haven for smugglers.

Enjoy one of our perfectly crafted specialty cocktails under the open-air tiki, tap your foot to the live music, spend game day cheering on your favorite team or enjoy a relaxing evening dining fireside while overlooking the water on historic Bimini Row. Not ready to leave paradise? Take a piece home with our original  Rum Runner recipe.

Menus

Starters & Snacks

  • Homemade Smoked Fish Dip

    16
    Prepared with local catch, diced onions, jalapeños, pepperoncini, capers, tomatoes, lemon
  • Chicken Wings

    16
    Choice of: traditional or boneless. choice of: buffalo, jerk, dry rub or bbq
  • Coconut Fried Shrimp

    14
    Mango chili, pineapple salsa
  • Mahi Fish Bites

    18
    Lemon, yum yum sauce
  • Chips & Dips

    10
    Tri-color corn tortillas with guacamole, pico de gallo & warm queso
  • Jumbo Soft Pretzel

    10
    Served with horseradish mustard, queso
  • French Fries

    8
    House seasoning
  • Shrimp Cocktail

    20
    Served cold, with lemons & cocktail sauce
  • Grilled Jerk Shrimp

    20
    With pineapple salsa

Sandwiches

Comes with fries
  • PCI Burger

    18
    Signature blend of ground beef, american cheese, shredded lettuce, tomoato, oinion, pickles, housemade sauce, brioche bun
  • Islamorada Fish Sandwich

    20
    Catch of the day (grilled, blackened, or fried) lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pickles, pineapple salsa, toasted bun, yum yum sauce
  • Fried Chicken Sliders

    16
    Buttermilk fried, nashville hot sauce, sliced pickles, toasted bun
  • Chicken Quesadilla

    18
    Flour tortilla, peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, guacamole, pico
  • Shrimp Quesadilla

    22
    Flour tortilla, peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, guacamole, pico

Tacos

  • Mahi Fish Tacos

    20
    Island slaw, pineapple salsa, yum yum sauce, soft flour tortilla (served hot)
  • Ahi Tuna Tacos

    22
    Avocado wakame seaweed salad, sriracha sauce, honey-wasabi aioli, soft flour tortillas
  • Keys Blackened Mahi Salad

    20
    Mix greens, tomato, pineapple salsa, cucumber

Hook & Cook

  • Hook & Cook

    16

Tiki Time Cocktails

  • Rum Crawlers

    15
    Cartel rum, diplomatico rum, appleton rum, orgeat, orange curacao, lime juice, cinnamon bitters
  • The Good Keys Life

    15
    Casamigos tequila, grand marnier, lime juice, earl grey agave
  • Postcard Paloma

    15
    Milagro tequila, giffard pamplemousse, lime juice, monin pineberry, grapefruit soda
  • Smokey Tiki Rita

    15
    Dos hombres mezcal, lime juice, simple syrup, top off red wine
  • Overseas Sunset Sangria

    15
    New amsterdam vodka, aperol, moscato, agave, passion fruit, merlot
  • Indigo Midnight

    15
    Woodford reserve, pineapple, orange juice, topped off with ginger beer
  • Floridora Isladora

    15
    Botanist gin, simple syrup, lime juice, raspberries, butterfly pea flowers
  • Passion Por Mi Amor

    15
    Don q rum, passion fruit, orange juice, campari

Frozen Favorites

Add a Dark Rum Floater for $3
  • The Original Rum Runner

    14
    Our signature cocktail since forever. frozen or hand shaken. bacardi superior rum, bacardi black, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, pineapple juice, lime juice, grenadine
    • Dark Rum Floater $3.00
  • Key Lime Colada

    14
    Keke beach key lime liqueur, bacardi, tropeka ice creme, lime juice, coco lopez
    • Dark Rum Floater $3.00
  • Pineapple Shipwreck

    14
    Bacardi, tropeka pina colada blend
    • Dark Rum Floater $3.00
  • Low Tide Tiki Mudslide

    14
    Bacardi, creme de cacao, tropeka ice cream
    • Dark Rum Floater $3.00

Wine

  • Casa Lunardi, Pinot Grigio, Italy

  • Giesen, Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand

  • Starmont, Chardonnay, California

  • Sea Sun, Pinot Noir, California

  • Substance, Cabernet Sauvignon

  • Tutto Mio, Sweet Red

  • St. Francis, Merlot

  • Unshackled, Red Blend

  • Wycliff Sparkling

  • Caposaldo, Moscato

  • August Kessler, Riesling

  • Daou, Rose

Beer on Tap

  • Modelo

    0
  • Lagunitas IPA

    0
  • Sam Adams

    0
  • Corona

    0
  • Voodoo Ranger

    0
  • Blue Moon

    0

Cans

  • Bud Light

    0
  • Budweiser

    0
  • Coors Light

    0
  • Miller Light

    0
  • Michelob Ultra

    0
  • Truly Variety

    0
  • Corona Premier

    0
  • Heineken

    0
  • Stella Artois

    0
  • Sierra Nevada

    0
  • Angry Orchard Cider

    0

Local Beer

  • Crazy Lady Honey Blonde Ale

    0
  • Florida Keys Iguana Bait

    0
  • Islamorada Citrus Ale

    0
  • Islamorada Sandbar Sunday

    0
  • Florida Keys Spearfish Amber Ale

    0
  • Florida Keys Sunsessional IPA

    0
Single Platform banner

For kids 12 and under

Main

  • Chicken Tenders

    10
  • Hot Dog

    10
  • Grilled Cheese

    10
  • Mac and Cheese

    10
Single Platform banner

Events Calendar

Authentic island experiences are always on our calendar. See what’s happening at Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina.

2 Adults, 0 Children
-
+
-
+
Book Today