Islamorada Resort Collection
|

Tiki Bar

World-Famous Home of the Rum Runner

A long-time favorite haunt among locals and guests, Tiki Bar is a bucket-list-busting island institution worth the trip alone. Serving up tropical cocktails, fresh seafood, and good times for over 50 years, it's also home to the famed Rum Runner cocktail. A fabled libation created to use up surplus bar inventory, this legendary concoction pays homage to the Keys' early history as a haven for smugglers.

Enjoy one of our perfectly crafted specialty cocktails under the open-air tiki, tap your foot to the live music, spend game day cheering on your favorite team or enjoy a relaxing evening dining fireside while overlooking the water on historic Bimini Row. Not ready to leave paradise? Take a piece home with our original  Rum Runner recipe.

Hours & Contact

Hours of Operation

Hours

Sun – Thurs | 8am – 12am

Fri - Sat | 8am - 1am

Menus

  • Gluten Free
  • Vegetarian
  • Vegan

Starters & Snacks

  • Homemade Smoked Fish Dip

    16
    Prepared with local catch, diced onions, jalapeños, pepperoncini, capers, tomatoes, lemon

  • Chicken Wings

    16
    Choice of: traditional or boneless. choice of: buffalo, jerk, dry rub or bbq

  • Coconut Fried Shrimp

    14
    Mango chili, pineapple salsa

  • Mahi Fish Bites

    18
    Lemon, yum yum sauce

  • Chips & Dips

    10
    Tri-color corn tortillas with guacamole, pico de gallo & warm queso

  • Jumbo Soft Pretzel

    10
    Served with horseradish mustard, queso

  • French Fries

    8
    House seasoning

  • Shrimp Cocktail

    20
    Served cold, with lemons & cocktail sauce

  • Grilled Jerk Shrimp

    20
    With pineapple salsa
Back to top

Sandwiches

Comes with fries

  • PCI Burger

    18
    Signature blend of ground beef, american cheese, shredded lettuce, tomoato, oinion, pickles, housemade sauce, brioche bun

  • Islamorada Fish Sandwich

    20
    Catch of the day (grilled, blackened, or fried) lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pickles, pineapple salsa, toasted bun, yum yum sauce

  • Fried Chicken Sliders

    16
    Buttermilk fried, nashville hot sauce, sliced pickles, toasted bun

  • Chicken Quesadilla

    18
    Flour tortilla, peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, guacamole, pico

  • Shrimp Quesadilla

    22
    Flour tortilla, peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, guacamole, pico
Back to top

Tacos

  • Mahi Fish Tacos

    20
    Island slaw, pineapple salsa, yum yum sauce, soft flour tortilla (served hot)

  • Ahi Tuna Tacos

    22
    Avocado wakame seaweed salad, sriracha sauce, honey-wasabi aioli, soft flour tortillas

  • Keys Blackened Mahi Salad

    20
    Mix greens, tomato, pineapple salsa, cucumber
Back to top

Hook & Cook

  • Hook & Cook

    16
Back to top

Tiki Time Cocktails

  • Rum Crawlers

    15
    Cartel rum, diplomatico rum, appleton rum, orgeat, orange curacao, lime juice, cinnamon bitters

  • The Good Keys Life

    15
    Casamigos tequila, grand marnier, lime juice, earl grey agave

  • Postcard Paloma

    15
    Milagro tequila, giffard pamplemousse, lime juice, monin pineberry, grapefruit soda

  • Smokey Tiki Rita

    15
    Dos hombres mezcal, lime juice, simple syrup, top off red wine

  • Overseas Sunset Sangria

    15
    New amsterdam vodka, aperol, moscato, agave, passion fruit, merlot

  • Indigo Midnight

    15
    Woodford reserve, pineapple, orange juice, topped off with ginger beer

  • Floridora Isladora

    15
    Botanist gin, simple syrup, lime juice, raspberries, butterfly pea flowers

  • Passion Por Mi Amor

    15
    Don q rum, passion fruit, orange juice, campari
Back to top

Frozen Favorites

Add a Dark Rum Floater for $3

  • The Original Rum Runner

    14
    Our signature cocktail since forever. frozen or hand shaken. bacardi superior rum, bacardi black, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, pineapple juice, lime juice, grenadine
    • Dark Rum Floater $3.00

  • Key Lime Colada

    14
    Keke beach key lime liqueur, bacardi, tropeka ice creme, lime juice, coco lopez
    • Dark Rum Floater $3.00

  • Pineapple Shipwreck

    14
    Bacardi, tropeka pina colada blend
    • Dark Rum Floater $3.00

  • Low Tide Tiki Mudslide

    14
    Bacardi, creme de cacao, tropeka ice cream
    • Dark Rum Floater $3.00
Back to top

Wine

  • Casa Lunardi, Pinot Grigio, Italy

  • Giesen, Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand

  • Starmont, Chardonnay, California

  • Sea Sun, Pinot Noir, California

  • Substance, Cabernet Sauvignon

  • Tutto Mio, Sweet Red

  • St. Francis, Merlot

  • Unshackled, Red Blend

  • Wycliff Sparkling

  • Caposaldo, Moscato

  • August Kessler, Riesling

  • Daou, Rose

Back to top

Beer on Tap

  • Modelo

    0

  • Lagunitas IPA

    0

  • Sam Adams

    0

  • Corona

    0

  • Voodoo Ranger

    0

  • Blue Moon

    0
Back to top

Cans

  • Bud Light

    0

  • Budweiser

    0

  • Coors Light

    0

  • Miller Light

    0

  • Michelob Ultra

    0

  • Truly Variety

    0

  • Corona Premier

    0

  • Heineken

    0

  • Stella Artois

    0

  • Sierra Nevada

    0

  • Angry Orchard Cider

    0
Back to top

Local Beer

  • Crazy Lady Honey Blonde Ale

    0

  • Florida Keys Iguana Bait

    0

  • Islamorada Citrus Ale

    0

  • Islamorada Sandbar Sunday

    0

  • Florida Keys Spearfish Amber Ale

    0

  • Florida Keys Sunsessional IPA

    0
Back to top
Single Platform banner

For kids 12 and under

Main

  • Chicken Tenders

    10

  • Hot Dog

    10

  • Grilled Cheese

    10

  • Mac and Cheese

    10
Back to top
Single Platform banner
couple on jetskis

Events Calendar

Authentic island experiences are always on our calendar. See what’s happening at Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina.

View Events
2 Adults, 0 Children
Book Today